Friends, it appears that we are on the cusp of both an immigration reign of terror and a transformation of the way government works in the United States. I do not believe Trump was elected to turn American democracy into a dictatorship. He was elected primarily because of the post-covid unhappiness and worry of many Americans caused by the inflation which happened during the last two years of the Biden presidency. We Democrats also lost many in the working class—which historically has been our base– because of their unhappiness with the status quo, particularly the economy, and their distrust of “political correctness” by many Democrats, not because they wanted Trump to deport 11 million undocumented workers, fire the generals and career civil servants, end climate initiatives, shred the social safety net, champion more tax cuts for the ultra-rich, and curtail vaccines and public health initiatives. They voted for him, hoping for an economy that is fairer and where they do not have to struggle from paycheck to paycheck. Why they chose Trump remains a mystery, but it will gradually become obvious to them that they picked the wrong horse when high tariffs and fewer immigrant workers cause more inflation and government social safety net programs are decimated. But that will take time. And what are we to do in the meantime—especially regarding the draconian deportation of undocumented immigrants?
Some have cautioned not to take Trump’s pledge to imprison and deport 11 million undocumented residents seriously. There is no way he could pull this off, they argue. He will surely move to the center. Some of these are the same people that said that before passing judgement on Trump’s pledge to unravel what he calls the deep state we should look at whom he appoints as cabinet members and advisors. During his first term, they were mostly moderates and capable people, Well, not this time.The evidence is now in. Trump’s nominations include crackpots, sex offenders, and nutcases. No one he has nominated has the experience required to run a government department and all are sycophants.
What can we do? The starting point is the American Civil Liberties Union. For months the ACLU has been anticipating what Trump will do if reelected.
The ACLU maintains that Trump will not be able to accomplish his objectives on immigration without violating federal laws and the U.S. Constitution. They sued the government during Trump’s first term numerous times and won lawsuits that stopped the separation of families at the border, the arbitrary termination of asylum, stripping away the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), and adding a citizenship question to the 2020 census. They believe that many of Trump’s likely deportation actions starting in 2025 will run afoul of the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which prohibits unreasonable searches and seizures, including arrests and detentions without individualized suspicions. They also cite the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments, which guarantee equal protection of the laws by law enforcement and point out that there is no exception for immigrants. They also contend that there is no inherent rule in the Constitution or anywhere else that distinguishes legal protections for U.S. citizens that exclude undocumented people–“not language, not place of birth, not even the manner of their entry into the United States.” Specifically, the Fifth Amendment due process clause and the Constitution Suspension Clause also safeguard the writ of habeaus corpus, which protects individuals against unlawful imprisonment. The ACLU also believes that diverting funds to build the detention camps violates federal funding statues and that federalizing the National Guard and deploying the military to carry out deportation is illegal. The ACLU has won many cases involving these unconstitutional and illegal government actions in the past and is geared up to take these on again. They provide a set of legal guardrails that could stop the worst from happening. But then again, who knows what will happen with the Robert’s Supreme Court?
Another potential guard rail is provided by sanctuary cities. Many cities, counties and states have passed laws that limit cooperation with the federal government regarding immigration by declaring themselves “sanctuary cities.” The term refers to a city (or a county, or a state) that limits its cooperation with federal immigration enforcement agents to protect low-priority immigrants from deportation, while turning over those who have committed serious crimes. In mid 2024 there were approximately 600 sanctuary jurisdictions of differing sizes across the country.
In January 2017, Trump signed an executive order requiring sanctuary cities to comply with federal immigration laws or else have federal funding pulled. But in April of that year, a San Francisco judge blocked the order saying that the president had overstepped his powers by trying to tie billions in federal funding to immigration enforcement. Only Congress could place such conditions on spending.
There are also “welcoming cities,” which are pro-immigration but not specifically opposed to federal action which affects immigrants. While sanctuary policies focus on not cooperating with immigration authorities, welcoming cities are more generally focused around creating a welcoming and supportive environment for immigrants, though this does not preclude opposing federal deportations. There are currently 24 certified “welcoming jurisdictions” in the U.S. Many of those that do not prohibit cooperation are considering adding that to their charter.
The good news is that some guard rails are in place to slow down the deportation process and that there will be opposition to Trump’s mass deportation of immigrants. The bad news is that we are not sure that the guard rails will hold or that they will significantly impair Trump’s deportation promises.
While the situation is terrifying to those who are not documented and to those who love them, I am hopeful that the worst will be averted. Some of the guardrails will hold, and there will be pushback from many others who will be horrified when they realize what is happening. While we are flawed, we are not an evil country. Good and decent people are in the majority. People will not sit idly by and watch the pain and suffering happen without taking action.
There will be a Resistance Movement. But what will the Resistance Movement look like? I think that the Civil Rights Movement in the 1960s and the Anti War Movement in the 1970s provide some clues. Embry and I were both involved in the Civil Rights Movement when we worked with SNCC in Southwest Georgia in 1966. We also participated in protests against the Vietnam War. I believe that when the arrests and deportations start, we will see mass demonstrations, protests, marches, and peaceful civil disobedience like what happened more than fifty years ago. The main question I have is who is going to lead this effort. Is there a Martin Luther King Jr out there somewhere (who is an immigrant) or others who will inspire and rally people to the cause? What will our institutions do, especially the churches? This seems like a perfect opportunity for churches to provide asylum and protection and to take a stand against Trump’s deportation actions and for church leaders to step up to the plate. This will be a time when people will have to make decisions–to join the Resistance or not. Sitting this one out is a tacit endorsement of the Trump agenda.
Let the Resistance Movement begin now!